2009:Indiana Hoosier Daddies-Pat DeBonis

2008:Tampico Stogies-Tyler Merriam
2007:Rushmore Red Doggs-Roger Merriam
2006:Rushmore Red Doggs-Roger Merriam
2005:Boys of Summer-John Maggi                                                                                            2004:Middle Earth Hobbits-Tom Trella
2003:Buffalo Black Sox-Kelly Johnson
2002:Buffalo Black Sox-Kelly Johnson
2001:New York Knights-Billy Vanson
2000:Razor Valley Razorbacks-Troy Milton
1999:The Empire-Pat DeBonis/Martin Seeboth
1998:New York Knights-Billy Vanson
1997:Rushmore Red Doggs-Roger Merriam
1996:New Jersey Sentinels-Bob Spellerberg
1995:New Jersey Sentinels-Bob Spellerberg
1994:New Jersey Sentinels-Bob Spellerberg
1993:The Empire-Pat DeBonis/Martin Seeboth
1992:New Jersey Sentinels-Bob Spellerberg
1991:The Empire-Pat DeBonis/Martin Seeboth
1990:New York Knights-Billy Vanson
1989:Hartford Chiefs-Pat DeBonis
1988:Temple Hills Express-Martin Seeboth/Scott Schnurr
1987:Orangeville Wolverines-Ken Risner
1986:Hartford Chiefs-Pat DeBonis
1985:Temple Hills Express-Martin Seeboth/Scott Schnurr